--- title: A Closer Look at the Vahalla Train Accident description: Railroad lawyer puts deadly Valhalla New York car train accident into context of crossing dangers nationwide. image: https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hub/312738/file-2448751898.jpg --- [![fw-fela-logo.png](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/fw-fela-logo.png?width=504&name=fw-fela-logo.png "fw-fela-logo.png")](https://www.felaattorney.com/) ![lpheader-blog-header.jpg](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/LP_Headers/lpheader-blog-header.jpg?width=1024&name=lpheader-blog-header.jpg "lpheader-blog-header.jpg") ## FELA Attorney's Blog | Exploring the rights and issues of railroad workers and rail passengers # A Closer Look at the Vahalla Train Accident Posted by [Marc Wietzke](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/author/marc-wietzke) on Feb 6, 2015 5:00:00 AM - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) ![metro north valhalla train accident](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hub/312738/file-2448751898.jpg?width=1024&name=file-2448751898.jpg "metro north valhalla train accident") This week’s [deadly car and Metro North train accident](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/metro-north-deadly-valhalla-train-crash-could-have-been-avoided) in New York shined a light on the danger drivers, passengers and railroad workers face at crossings.   *In today’s post we’ll take a deeper look at the Commerce Street crossing and put its accident history in context of rail crossings nationwide. *   Documents filed by Metro North with the federal government before the accident show that the Commerce Street crossing where the accident occurred in Valhalla had an average of 107 train crossings per day.   The railroad and public will most likely say, “It must be safe if that many trains have crossed without incident.” But if 10 people crossed thin ice and only one falls in, that doesn't mean the ice is safe, it just means that nine people got lucky.   What the records don’t show is how many close calls there were at the crossing. We do know, also based on federal documents, that there was a driver killed at this crossing in 1984. At the time of that accident there was no interaction between the crossing gates and the traffic lights. The results of that investigation showed that the accident was the result of the driver trying to beat the gates. The federal records also show that the connection with the traffic signals was installed after Metro North took over.   The speed for trains in the area is 40 to 60 miles per hour, and [preliminary reports put this train at 58 miles per hour at the time of impact.](http://news.yahoo.com/suv-ended-tracks-center-probe-deadly-crash-070159272.html) We will probably learn the exact speed this week. I confirmed Wednesday that the type of sensors on crossing gates which communicate an obstruction to the engineer were installed on the LIRR over 15 years ago.   There is also a real question as to whether the third rail which provides the power for the train turned off quickly enough once the accident occurred. If not, then this greatly increased the damage, and most likely loss of life, in the accident. Based on these types of collisions around the country, we typically see only the front end of the lead car involved in the accident. Most often, it is from the explosion of the gas tank of the vehicle. Because the gasoline burns so quickly, there is rarely any fuel left for the fire. However here, the amount of damage cannot be exclusively from the vehicle.   In 2013 there were over [2,080 crossing incidents](http://oli.org/about-us/news/collisions-casulties) in this country – 251 deaths, 929 injuries. That’s an average of more than five per day. (These numbers don't even include close calls that go unreported.) In other words, based on the most recent year we have statistics, at least 3 people every single day are either killed or injured at railroad grade crossings.   [As I said in a previous post, this is a problem we on the inside know exists](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/metro-north-deadly-valhalla-train-crash-could-have-been-avoided), but the danger of which the regular driver doesn’t realize.   In your opinion, what could the railroad do to reduce the amount of accidents and loss of life at crossings?   [Photo by Marc Wietzke](https://www.felaattorney.com/)   [![Get your railroad news instantly. Click here to subscribe to our blog.](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/312738/aed9bd74-40c7-413c-a420-4c0c0bc5582a.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/312738/aed9bd74-40c7-413c-a420-4c0c0bc5582a) Topics: [Railroad safety issues](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/railroad-safety-issues), [commuter](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/commuter), [Train accidents](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/train-accidents) ### Subscribe to Email Updates ### Recent Posts ### Posts by Topic - [FELA injury (31)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/fela-injury) - [FAQs on the job injuries (24)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/faqs-on-the-job-injuries) - [Basic steps to filing a fela lawsuit (20)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/basic-steps-to-filing-a-fela-lawsuit) - [Railroad safety issues (19)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/railroad-safety-issues) - [FELA recovery (15)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/fela-recovery) - [whistleblower (13)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/whistleblower) - [Rights of Railroad workers (11)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/rights-of-railroad-workers) - [settlements (10)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/settlements) - [reporting safety concerns (8)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/reporting-safety-concerns) - [how to file a claim against railroad (7)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/how-to-file-a-claim-against-railroad) - [verdict (7)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/verdict) - [how much is my case worth? (6)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/how-much-is-my-case-worth) - [how to file your own injury claim (6)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/how-to-file-your-own-injury-claim) - [how to hire a railroad lawyer (6)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/how-to-hire-a-railroad-lawyer) - [trials (6)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/trials) - [FELA v Workers' Comp (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/fela-v-workers-comp) - [Passenger railroad injuries (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/passenger-railroad-injuries) - [Train accidents (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/train-accidents) - [commuter (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/commuter) - [unions (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/unions) - [Checklist for hiring railroad lawyer (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/checklist-for-hiring-railroad-lawyer) - [LIRR (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/lirr) - [PEB (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/peb) - [amtrak (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/amtrak) - [compensatory damages (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/compensatory-damages) - [injured passengers (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/injured-passengers) - [lost wages (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/lost-wages) - [eye injury (3)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/eye-injury) - [wage loss calculator (3)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/wage-loss-calculator) - [Hoboken crash 2016 (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/hoboken-crash-2016) - [LIRR strike (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/lirr-strike) - [NJ Transit (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/nj-transit) - [NTSB (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/ntsb) - [PEB 245 (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/peb-245) - [Thoughts on the legal industry (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/thoughts-on-the-legal-industry) - [attacked at work (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/attacked-at-work) - [surveillance (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/surveillance) - [Engineers (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/engineers) - [FRR deep dive into Metro-North safety culture (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/frr-deep-dive-into-metro-north-safety-culture) - [MTA (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/mta) - [Medical forms (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/medical-forms) - [Metro North (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/metro-north) - [Multiple injuries (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/multiple-injuries) - [Railroad blogs to read (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/railroad-blogs-to-read) - [crude oil (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/crude-oil) - [finger injury (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/finger-injury) - [hosptial (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/hosptial) - [medical marijuana (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/medical-marijuana) - [punitive damages (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/punitive-damages) - [railroad injury deposition (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/railroad-injury-deposition) [see all](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/a-closer-look-at-the-vahalla-train-accident#) ### About Us ![Flynn Wietzke FELA injury attorneys](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/fw-fela-logo-drkbkg.png?width=504&name=fw-fela-logo-drkbkg.png "Flynn Wietzke FELA injury attorneys") Railroad lawyer Marc Wietzke focuses on FELA injury and whistleblower law for railroad workers injured or punished on the job. ### Services - [Home](https://www.felaattorney.com/) - [About Us](https://www.felaattorney.com/about-us) - [Wins](https://www.felaattorney.com/wins) - [Blog](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog) - [Contact Us](https://www.felaattorney.com/contact-us) ### From Blog --- ### Main Office 1205 Franklin Avenue, Garden City, NY 11530 T: (516) 877-1234 • F: (516) 877-1177 *With offices throughout the country [![Super Lawyers since 2014](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/new-fela-super-lawyers-logo-white-since-2014.png?width=150&height=150&name=new-fela-super-lawyers-logo-white-since-2014.png)](http://profiles.superlawyers.com/new-york-metro/garden-city/lawyer/marc-wietzke/11f74a17-3aee-4c7b-98a7-8a2f7803ab57.html) [![Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/multimillion-dollar-advocates-forum.png?width=150&height=150&name=multimillion-dollar-advocates-forum.png)](http://milliondollaradvocates.com/) [![ARLA](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/arla-footer.png?width=150&height=150&name=arla-footer.png)](http://www.arladepot.org/officers.html) [![10 Best Attorney 2017 American Institute of Personal Injury Attorneys](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/ten-best-attorney.png?width=150&height=150&name=ten-best-attorney.png)](http://aiopia.org/) [![Best Attorney of America Lifetime Charter Member](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/best-attorney-of-america-lifetime-charter-member.png?width=150&height=150&name=best-attorney-of-america-lifetime-charter-member.png)](https://www.bestattorneysofamerica.com/) [![Best Law Firms of America Lifetime Member](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/best-law-firms-of-america-footer.png?width=150&height=150&name=best-law-firms-of-america-footer.png)](https://bestlawfirmsofamerica.com/) --- ***ATTORNEY ADVERTISING - ***Prior results don’t guarantee a similar outcome in your claim. This website and blog are for informational purposes and do not constitute legal advice, since only after knowing the details of your claim can any advice be provided. Please understand that particular laws vary by state. You must speak directly with an attorney about your situation to determine what laws apply.   PRIVACY POLICY - As a law firm, we do not share any information received from any contact without that contact's specific permission.