--- title: Appeals Court Reverses Decision in Bala v PATH Whistleblower Case description: Appeals court reversed the landmark Bala vs Path whistelblower decision protecting a railroad worker's right to follow doctor's orders image: https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hub/312738/file-2360671312.jpg --- [![fw-fela-logo.png](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/fw-fela-logo.png?width=504&name=fw-fela-logo.png "fw-fela-logo.png")](https://www.felaattorney.com/) ![lpheader-blog-header.jpg](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/LP_Headers/lpheader-blog-header.jpg?width=1024&name=lpheader-blog-header.jpg "lpheader-blog-header.jpg") ## FELA Attorney's Blog | Exploring the rights and issues of railroad workers and rail passengers # Appeals Court Reverses Decision in Bala v PATH Whistleblower Case Posted by [Marc Wietzke](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/author/marc-wietzke) on Jan 17, 2015 10:24:02 AM - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) ![DSCF0714-103154-edited](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hub/312738/file-2360671312.jpg)Railroad workers' rights took a hit this week when a federal appellate court reversed the decision of the Administrative Review Board in Bala vs PATH. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals, reversed the ARB decision, which protected a workers right to follow doctors's orders. This was one of the [13 ways of triggering the Whistleblower protections](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/10-reasons-you-might-have-a-whistleblower-claim-against-railroad) of the Federal Railroad Safety Act (FRSA). [You can download the decision here.](https://www.felaattorney.com/decision-reversing-federal-whistleblower-case-bala-v-path) Bala vs PATH was the 2013 decision that prevented a carrier from disciplining an employee who was following doctors orders, regardless of whether the underlying condition was work related or not.  The reversal means that in those courts within the Third Circuit, only a doctor note pertaining to an on the job injury gives protection to the employee. Concussion at home when something falls from the garage shelf, making you dizzy? *Not excused.* Stomach bug has you throwing up? *Not excused. * These absences can still be counted for purposes of attendance policies. **This means that workers can ****be disciplined for absences when they follow a doctor's order not to return to work. **This will have long term ramifications as well as immediate. ### * Worker's currently suing the railroad in the affected courts for such an issue could see their whole cases invalidated.* If you think your claim will be affected, speak to a railroad lawyer right away. [![Wondering how this will affect you?  Click to ask attorney Marc Wietzke](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/312738/69e0e03e-4068-4c99-a779-a711bf68f7e3.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/312738/69e0e03e-4068-4c99-a779-a711bf68f7e3) However, going forward, there are a couple of responses or workarounds that workers and their union reps can use. ## *Response one: Is the health issue a safety hazard?* The first is to determine whether by reporting his health issue and following doctors orders ***he is really reporting a safety hazard***.  In other words, ask the doctor to comment on whether the treatment (physical or medication) or condition itself, make the employee a danger to himself or others on the job. If so, it is a safety hazard. This takes it out of Section (c)2 at issue in the ruling and puts it into section (b) which has no work related qualification. ## *Response two: Is the underlying health issue related to work?* The next consideration is ***whether the doctor relates the underlying condition to work***, even if it isn't a problem that necessarily would give rise to an FELA claim (I.e. it wasn't railroad negligence), but is work related injury nonetheless. This takes care of the concern raised by the court in the decision. For example, did you just lose your footing while walking across tracks? Maybe you shut your hand in the door or were hurt in a car accident on the job. Assume none of these are the railroads fault. Where they nonetheless give rise to injuries which are work-related, doctor notes can protect against discipline.   On a related note, this is only the first court to rule on it, and there are cases in the 6th and 2nd circuit percolating too, so a US Supreme Court showdown is coming, but likely a couple years off.     I just wanted to comment on the decision since it will inevitably result in changes. For example, I can envision modification to recent policy changes at some railroads on doctor excused absences to include a modification allowing notes for job related injuries only.     If you think this decision will affect a claim you have made or were contemplating ([remember, you only have 180 days](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/how-long-do-i-have-to-file-a-railroad-lawsuit)), take all your claims and concerns to a railroad injury lawyer. Even if you think the ruling means you no longer have a claim, let the attorney put it into perspective during a free consultation.   [If you think you have a whistleblower claim affected by this decision, click to ask the advice of a railroad attorney.](https://www.felaattorney.com/ask-fela-attorney-marc-wietzke) ![](https://ssl.gstatic.com/ui/v1/icons/mail/images/cleardot.gif) ***You can read the entire Bala vs PATH decision yourself by downloading it here.***   [![Bala v path whistleblower case decision reversed](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/312738/1506afce-3874-4ca6-95aa-cc814ea56f4d.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/312738/1506afce-3874-4ca6-95aa-cc814ea56f4d)     Topics: [FAQs on the job injuries](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/faqs-on-the-job-injuries), [Rights of Railroad workers](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/rights-of-railroad-workers), [whistleblower](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/whistleblower), [reporting safety concerns](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/reporting-safety-concerns), [how much is my case worth?](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/how-much-is-my-case-worth) ### Subscribe to Email Updates ### Recent Posts ### Posts by Topic - [FELA injury (31)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/fela-injury) - [FAQs on the job injuries (24)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/faqs-on-the-job-injuries) - [Basic steps to filing a fela lawsuit (20)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/basic-steps-to-filing-a-fela-lawsuit) - [Railroad safety issues (19)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/railroad-safety-issues) - [FELA recovery (15)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/fela-recovery) - [whistleblower (13)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/whistleblower) - [Rights of Railroad workers (11)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/rights-of-railroad-workers) - [settlements (10)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/settlements) - [reporting safety concerns (8)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/reporting-safety-concerns) - [how to file a claim against railroad (7)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/how-to-file-a-claim-against-railroad) - [verdict (7)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/verdict) - [how much is my case worth? (6)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/how-much-is-my-case-worth) - [how to file your own injury claim (6)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/how-to-file-your-own-injury-claim) - [how to hire a railroad lawyer (6)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/how-to-hire-a-railroad-lawyer) - [trials (6)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/trials) - [FELA v Workers' Comp (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/fela-v-workers-comp) - [Passenger railroad injuries (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/passenger-railroad-injuries) - [Train accidents (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/train-accidents) - [commuter (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/commuter) - [unions (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/unions) - [Checklist for hiring railroad lawyer (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/checklist-for-hiring-railroad-lawyer) - [LIRR (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/lirr) - [PEB (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/peb) - [amtrak (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/amtrak) - [compensatory damages (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/compensatory-damages) - [injured passengers (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/injured-passengers) - [lost wages (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/lost-wages) - [eye injury (3)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/eye-injury) - [wage loss calculator (3)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/wage-loss-calculator) - [Hoboken crash 2016 (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/hoboken-crash-2016) - [LIRR strike (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/lirr-strike) - [NJ Transit (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/nj-transit) - [NTSB (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/ntsb) - [PEB 245 (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/peb-245) - [Thoughts on the legal industry (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/thoughts-on-the-legal-industry) - [attacked at work (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/attacked-at-work) - [surveillance (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/surveillance) - [Engineers (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/engineers) - [FRR deep dive into Metro-North safety culture (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/frr-deep-dive-into-metro-north-safety-culture) - [MTA (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/mta) - [Medical forms (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/medical-forms) - [Metro North (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/metro-north) - [Multiple injuries (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/multiple-injuries) - [Railroad blogs to read (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/railroad-blogs-to-read) - [crude oil (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/crude-oil) - [finger injury (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/finger-injury) - [hosptial (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/hosptial) - [medical marijuana (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/medical-marijuana) - [punitive damages (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/punitive-damages) - [railroad injury deposition (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/railroad-injury-deposition) [see all](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/appeals-court-reverses-decision-in-bala-v-path-whistleblower-case#) ### About Us ![Flynn Wietzke FELA injury attorneys](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/fw-fela-logo-drkbkg.png?width=504&name=fw-fela-logo-drkbkg.png "Flynn Wietzke FELA injury attorneys") Railroad lawyer Marc Wietzke focuses on FELA injury and whistleblower law for railroad workers injured or punished on the job. ### Services - [Home](https://www.felaattorney.com/) - [About Us](https://www.felaattorney.com/about-us) - [Wins](https://www.felaattorney.com/wins) - [Blog](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog) - [Contact Us](https://www.felaattorney.com/contact-us) ### From Blog --- ### Main Office 1205 Franklin Avenue, Garden City, NY 11530 T: (516) 877-1234 • F: (516) 877-1177 *With offices throughout the country [![Super Lawyers since 2014](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/new-fela-super-lawyers-logo-white-since-2014.png?width=150&height=150&name=new-fela-super-lawyers-logo-white-since-2014.png)](http://profiles.superlawyers.com/new-york-metro/garden-city/lawyer/marc-wietzke/11f74a17-3aee-4c7b-98a7-8a2f7803ab57.html) [![Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/multimillion-dollar-advocates-forum.png?width=150&height=150&name=multimillion-dollar-advocates-forum.png)](http://milliondollaradvocates.com/) [![ARLA](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/arla-footer.png?width=150&height=150&name=arla-footer.png)](http://www.arladepot.org/officers.html) [![10 Best Attorney 2017 American Institute of Personal Injury Attorneys](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/ten-best-attorney.png?width=150&height=150&name=ten-best-attorney.png)](http://aiopia.org/) [![Best Attorney of America Lifetime Charter Member](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/best-attorney-of-america-lifetime-charter-member.png?width=150&height=150&name=best-attorney-of-america-lifetime-charter-member.png)](https://www.bestattorneysofamerica.com/) [![Best Law Firms of America Lifetime Member](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/best-law-firms-of-america-footer.png?width=150&height=150&name=best-law-firms-of-america-footer.png)](https://bestlawfirmsofamerica.com/) --- ***ATTORNEY ADVERTISING - ***Prior results don’t guarantee a similar outcome in your claim. This website and blog are for informational purposes and do not constitute legal advice, since only after knowing the details of your claim can any advice be provided. Please understand that particular laws vary by state. You must speak directly with an attorney about your situation to determine what laws apply.   PRIVACY POLICY - As a law firm, we do not share any information received from any contact without that contact's specific permission.