--- title: "Crude By Rail: It's What's Inside That Counts" description: In this post we'll explore the dangers in transport of crude oil by rail, which are behind some recent hazmat spills, and how they affect railroad worker safety. image: https://mail.google.com/mail/ca/u/0/images/cleardot.gif --- [![fw-fela-logo.png](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/fw-fela-logo.png?width=504&name=fw-fela-logo.png "fw-fela-logo.png")](https://www.felaattorney.com/) ![lpheader-blog-header.jpg](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/LP_Headers/lpheader-blog-header.jpg?width=1024&name=lpheader-blog-header.jpg "lpheader-blog-header.jpg") ## FELA Attorney's Blog | Exploring the rights and issues of railroad workers and rail passengers # Crude By Rail: It's What's Inside That Counts Posted by [Marc Wietzke](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/author/marc-wietzke) on Apr 24, 2014 5:52:00 PM - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) ![13520907943_50cf5cfbb6_z](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hub/312738/file-694252866.jpg?width=333&name=file-694252866.jpg)Those mundane but endless black tanker cars rumbling through cities and suburbs alike are cloaking a volatile offender: crude oil. In this post we'll explore the transport of the dangerous fuel behind some recent hazmat spills and how it affects railroad worker safety. This month [an executive from the Ohio Oil and Natural Gas Association was quoted in an Ohio paper ](http://www.mansfieldnewsjournal.com/article/B9/20140404/NEWS01/304040020/Officials-not-keeping-track-oil-trains)saying that the oil shipped through towns and cities all over the US is “ very volatile” and “basically liquified natural gas." The official went onto say, “It is still classified as crude oil, even thought it is a lot closer to gasoline.”   This is true for Bakken crude, coming out of the Bakken Oil shale in North Dakota, [which regulators have concluded is more flammable than regular crude](http://www.mcclatchydc.com/2014/02/25/219372/feds-ban-tank-cars-carrying-crude.html). Technically classified as crude oil, and thus handled according to a certain set of federal safety guidelines overseen by Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration, crude by rail (CBR) has picked up speed. For example in eastern Ohio alone, CBR shipments are up over 23%. [But with tanker car derailments, like last year's accident in Alabama, getting more attention, public concern is starting to rise as well.](http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/11/11/alabama-oil-train-derailment_n_4252887.html) Though the fervor of questions rises, it has come to light that those same federal regulators are left in the dark as to what is on the tracks at any given time. First responders and community officials are no help, since apart from getting a list of the top 25 hazardous materials that move through their communities, they are kept outside the loop. Because of security concerns, local officials can’t make the top 25 lists public. Railroads keep a list internally, but those records also are not public. The Association of American Railroads has started a preemptive woe-is-me defense to the inevitable accidents to come, saying “The shippers own the cars and the materials and are responsible for safe packaging and labeling, but we’re the ones liable in case of an accident”.   But who makes money on every mile of every tank car that comes rolling down the track? The railroads. So recently, [the AAR proposed tighter safety regulations relating to tank cars carrying combustible liquids](http://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2014/03/18/new-tank-car-regulations-proposed-by-aar-may-negatively-impact-railroads/). But where were they for the last two decades? This is hardly a new issue. Twenty years ago the [MacNeil/Lehrer News Hour](http://youtu.be/VgOZ2yWn1w8) did a piece on this precise point. What was it that brought the railroads into their new "proactive" stance? **Derailments.** So now the railroad is scrambling to claim moral high ground. They have to convince the nation that they are doing everything possible to improve their safety. According to rail industry officials, [U.S. freight railroads are estimated to have carried more than 400,000 carloads of crude oil in 2013](https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R43390.pdf) (roughly equivalent to 280 million barrels), compared to 9,500 carloads in 2008.   As much as [90 percent of the North Dakota's Bakken crude will move by freight rail ](http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2013/12/13/3061561/trains-north-dakota-oil-keystone/)[in 2014](http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2013/12/13/3061561/trains-north-dakota-oil-keystone/), more than the Keystone XL pipeline will transport. To be sure, oil industry officials are lagging on the issue too, having reached no specific decisions, merely stating “Our mitigation efforts are looking at topics like tank car design and crude oil testing and classification". [States can play an important part in the regulation of CBR](http://blogs.berkeley.edu/2014/03/31/as-oil-by-rail-gains-momentum-is-california-on-track-to-protect-human-health-and-the-environment/). But if the railroads refused to let the unsafe tanker cars travel on their tracks, the companies would comply. With CBR shipments on the rise, track maintenance needs to also be on the rise, but tanker car replacements should be at the forefront. [Photo by Joshua Putnam](https://www.flickr.com/photos/jputnam/13520907943/in/photolist-471EuR-475K7w-mANbSt-cBHPR7) [![](https://mail.google.com/mail/ca/u/0/images/cleardot.gif) ](https://www.flickr.com/photos/jputnam/13520907943/in/photolist-471EuR-475K7w-mANbSt-cBHPR7)[![reporting unsafe working conditions whistleblower claim](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/312738/1092745a-3c13-43d7-8169-26e98c41246b.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/312738/1092745a-3c13-43d7-8169-26e98c41246b) Topics: [Railroad safety issues](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/railroad-safety-issues), [crude oil](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/crude-oil) ### Subscribe to Email Updates ### Recent Posts ### Posts by Topic - [FELA injury (31)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/fela-injury) - [FAQs on the job injuries (24)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/faqs-on-the-job-injuries) - [Basic steps to filing a fela lawsuit (20)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/basic-steps-to-filing-a-fela-lawsuit) - [Railroad safety issues (19)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/railroad-safety-issues) - [FELA recovery (15)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/fela-recovery) - [whistleblower (13)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/whistleblower) - [Rights of Railroad workers (11)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/rights-of-railroad-workers) - [settlements (10)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/settlements) - [reporting safety concerns (8)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/reporting-safety-concerns) - [how to file a claim against railroad (7)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/how-to-file-a-claim-against-railroad) - [verdict (7)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/verdict) - [how much is my case worth? (6)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/how-much-is-my-case-worth) - [how to file your own injury claim (6)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/how-to-file-your-own-injury-claim) - [how to hire a railroad lawyer (6)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/how-to-hire-a-railroad-lawyer) - [trials (6)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/trials) - [FELA v Workers' Comp (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/fela-v-workers-comp) - [Passenger railroad injuries (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/passenger-railroad-injuries) - [Train accidents (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/train-accidents) - [commuter (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/commuter) - [unions (5)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/unions) - [Checklist for hiring railroad lawyer (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/checklist-for-hiring-railroad-lawyer) - [LIRR (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/lirr) - [PEB (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/peb) - [amtrak (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/amtrak) - [compensatory damages (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/compensatory-damages) - [injured passengers (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/injured-passengers) - [lost wages (4)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/lost-wages) - [eye injury (3)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/eye-injury) - [wage loss calculator (3)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/wage-loss-calculator) - [Hoboken crash 2016 (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/hoboken-crash-2016) - [LIRR strike (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/lirr-strike) - [NJ Transit (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/nj-transit) - [NTSB (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/ntsb) - [PEB 245 (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/peb-245) - [Thoughts on the legal industry (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/thoughts-on-the-legal-industry) - [attacked at work (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/attacked-at-work) - [surveillance (2)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/surveillance) - [Engineers (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/engineers) - [FRR deep dive into Metro-North safety culture (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/frr-deep-dive-into-metro-north-safety-culture) - [MTA (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/mta) - [Medical forms (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/medical-forms) - [Metro North (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/metro-north) - [Multiple injuries (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/multiple-injuries) - [Railroad blogs to read (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/railroad-blogs-to-read) - [crude oil (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/crude-oil) - [finger injury (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/finger-injury) - [hosptial (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/hosptial) - [medical marijuana (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/medical-marijuana) - [punitive damages (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/punitive-damages) - [railroad injury deposition (1)](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/topic/railroad-injury-deposition) [see all](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog/crude-by-rail-its-whats-inside-that-counts#) ### About Us ![Flynn Wietzke FELA injury attorneys](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/fw-fela-logo-drkbkg.png?width=504&name=fw-fela-logo-drkbkg.png "Flynn Wietzke FELA injury attorneys") Railroad lawyer Marc Wietzke focuses on FELA injury and whistleblower law for railroad workers injured or punished on the job. ### Services - [Home](https://www.felaattorney.com/) - [About Us](https://www.felaattorney.com/about-us) - [Wins](https://www.felaattorney.com/wins) - [Blog](https://www.felaattorney.com/blog) - [Contact Us](https://www.felaattorney.com/contact-us) ### From Blog --- ### Main Office 1205 Franklin Avenue, Garden City, NY 11530 T: (516) 877-1234 • F: (516) 877-1177 *With offices throughout the country [![Super Lawyers since 2014](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/new-fela-super-lawyers-logo-white-since-2014.png?width=150&height=150&name=new-fela-super-lawyers-logo-white-since-2014.png)](http://profiles.superlawyers.com/new-york-metro/garden-city/lawyer/marc-wietzke/11f74a17-3aee-4c7b-98a7-8a2f7803ab57.html) [![Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/multimillion-dollar-advocates-forum.png?width=150&height=150&name=multimillion-dollar-advocates-forum.png)](http://milliondollaradvocates.com/) [![ARLA](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/arla-footer.png?width=150&height=150&name=arla-footer.png)](http://www.arladepot.org/officers.html) [![10 Best Attorney 2017 American Institute of Personal Injury Attorneys](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/ten-best-attorney.png?width=150&height=150&name=ten-best-attorney.png)](http://aiopia.org/) [![Best Attorney of America Lifetime Charter Member](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/best-attorney-of-america-lifetime-charter-member.png?width=150&height=150&name=best-attorney-of-america-lifetime-charter-member.png)](https://www.bestattorneysofamerica.com/) [![Best Law Firms of America Lifetime Member](https://www.felaattorney.com/hs-fs/hubfs/best-law-firms-of-america-footer.png?width=150&height=150&name=best-law-firms-of-america-footer.png)](https://bestlawfirmsofamerica.com/) --- ***ATTORNEY ADVERTISING - ***Prior results don’t guarantee a similar outcome in your claim. This website and blog are for informational purposes and do not constitute legal advice, since only after knowing the details of your claim can any advice be provided. Please understand that particular laws vary by state. You must speak directly with an attorney about your situation to determine what laws apply.   PRIVACY POLICY - As a law firm, we do not share any information received from any contact without that contact's specific permission.